• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Videos

Charles Eisenstein

  • About
  • Essays
  • Videos
  • Podcasts
    • Charles Eisenstein Random
    • A New and Ancient Story Podcast
    • Outside Interviews
  • Courses
    • The Sanity Project
    • Climate — Inside and Out
    • Conversations with Orland Bishop, Course One
    • Conversations with Orland Bishop, Course Two
    • Conversations with Orland Bishop, Course Three
    • Dietary Transformation from the Inside Out
    • Living in the Gift
    • Masculinity: A New Story
    • Metaphysics & Mystery
    • Space Between Stories
    • Unlearning: For Change Agents
  • NAAS
  • Books
    • The Coronation
    • Climate — A New Story
    • The More Beautiful World Our Hearts Know Is Possible
    • The Ascent Of Humanity
    • Sacred Economics
    • The Yoga Of Eating
  • Events
  • Donate

Why We Think Only the Measurable is Real

April 2019


The notion that “only the measurable is real” is a deep reductionism that says all of the difference in the world is just number. But when we approach the world that way, we don’t create the world we really want.

From Charles’ presentation at the Science & Nonduality conference. Watch the full video here: https://youtu.be/Otyt-Moj-5g

#CharlesEisenstein #SAND #Science #Religion #Interbeing #Philosophy #Authors #PhilosophyQuotes #Inspiration

You can access a transcription of this talk here or below. Thank you to Eva Jasmijn Gunnewick!


Why We Think Only the Measurable is Real
Transcript of Charles Eisenstein’s Talk at SAND (Science & Non-Duality) Conference

The notion that “only the measurable is real” is a kind of reductionism that says that all of the difference, all of the uniqueness, every relationship in the world and the universe can be characterized by numbers. It’s a deeper kind of reductionism than just saying that everything is built of these building blocks and they are built of smaller building blocks, down to the atom and electron etcetera. This is a conceptual reductionism that says that all of the difference in the world is just number. And if you want to be scientific about something you have to be quantitative. I know graduate students who get into trouble with their professors because they haven’t quantified their hypotheses or subjected it to a quantifiable approach.

The problem with this idea that “only the measurable is real“ and the validation or the cult of quantity, is that when we approach the world that way and begin to make decisions based on the numbers… and where do we get that habit anyway? It’s from the money world, where you are supposed to make economic decisions based on essentially solving a max-min problem. It’s turned into a theory of human nature. That human being seek to maximize their rational self-interest. And then it’s extended into biology too. That all beings seek to maximize reproductive self-interest and are performing implicit calculations every time they make a choice or enact their genetic deprogrammed behavior, etcetera.

It sounds good, like science based policy, metrics based policy, but what happens is that it ignores everything that we choose not to measure, cannot measure or that is unmeasurable. Usually what we choose not to measure are the very things that would disrupt the status quo and the interests of the institutions that are already in power.

A prime example would be GDP as a measure for human wellbeing, as a measure for progress. So what is it actually a measure of? It’s a measure of the total amount of goods and services exchanged for money. And what does it leave out? It leaves out tradition, relationship, sacredness, beauty, it leaves out actually all of the things that make us rich: community, in fact it’s the opposite of community, because GDP grows when you convert relationships into services and the thing that people once did for each other without using money, like taking care of children, cooking, growing food, building houses, providing entertainment, singing songs, etcetera, get converted into paid services. So that’s what gets left out and when we see reality through the lens of the numbers that we accept, then everything else atrophies.

The same thing is happening in climate change. It’s such a familiar comfortable habit to focus on the numbers, that we look for the easiest way to do that: adopting a convenient problem in the place of an inconvenient problem that we don’t know how to solve. So the convenient problem and the comfortable problem is greenhouse gas emissions which we can measure on a global scale and which have a linear cause, the levels of greenhouse gas is caused by emissions, that we can attack. Here is the enemy, very comfortable. What gets left out and this is why I think that the climate change narrative is a disaster for environmentalism, because it sucks the air out of the room for any environmental issue that seems to have no bearing on climate change.

For example the whales. Remember the days of “Save the Whales”? That was an important environmental issue and now you never hear about saving the whales. Because what did the whales matter? It’s nice, we should save the whales, but what does it matter when we are facing near term extinction because of high greenhouse gasses? Well, maybe what we are missing is actually the salvation. Just to give an example, we decimate the whales, then the orcas are deprived of their major food source, so they begin to eat the seals and the sea otters and they decimate the seals and the sea otters, which then no longer predate the sea urchins, so the population of sea urchins explodes. Then the sea urchins decimate the kelp forests and the kelp forests actually sequester more carbon than land based forests. “Oh darn it, we should have included that chain of causality in our measurements. The whales are important after all.”

So from the mindset of the cult of quantity the solution to the failure of measurement is to measure even more. And the utopia of the metrics based approach to reality would be to encompass everything in one big dataset so that we could rationally administer the world through the precise application of force.



Previous: Why I Believe in a Living Planet View
Next: How Change Happens in the Story of Separation

Primary Sidebar

All Videos

From a PANDEMIC of CONTROL to a Paradise of Possibility W/ Dr. Zach Bush MD & Charles Eisenstein

Can Our COLLECTIVE MISTRUST Ever Be Repaired? w/ Charles Eisenstein | Aubrey Marcus Podcast

An Epidemic of Control, Charles Eisenstein

The Pandemic Is A Prism with PAUL KINGSNORTH & CHARLES EISENSTEIN [FULL SESSION]

Why Is The Climate Debate Such A Mess? – Charles Eisenstein | Modern Wisdom Podcast 382

And the Music Played the Band

Trust Your Heart

A Gathering of the Tribe

Systems of the Damned: Russell Brand & Charles Eisenstein – Under the Skin

Morphic Resonance and a New Reason for Activism

Amazon Rainforest Fires – Avoid This Trap

Campfire Stories – An Unlearning: My Meeting with Charles Eisenstein

Campfire Stories – On the Story of Separation and the Story of Interbeing

What Kind of World Do You Want to Live in?

Healing Our Democracy

Our Salvation Will Come From the Margins

Signs that Humanity is Returning to Loving a Living Earth

How Can We Reconnect with Our Love of Nature?

Where Does Love Come From ?

My Concern with Drawdown

Historic Denver Psilocybin Mushroom Vote 2019 – What Does It Mean?

How Can We Listen to the Earth?

Listen to and Participate with Gaia

The Core Themes of Climate: A New Story

Q&A Responses Batch 1 – Unlearning: For Change Agents

A Deeper Look at The Green New Deal

Charles Eisenstein on Brexit

A Message to Greta Thunberg and the Youth Climate Strikers

Full Session 1 Premiere from Unlearning For Change Agents

It Is No Measure of Health to be Well-Adjusted to a Profoundly Sick Society

Separation vs Interbeing

Archetypes and Stories Beyond the Hero’s Journey

The Wound of Separation

My Stance on Cryptocurrencies

How Can I Help Heal Our Planet?

Exiting the Matrix

Who Are You?

Can One Person Create a Big Change?

Moving Towards Interbeing

The Case for a Universal Basic Income

Is There Hope for the Planet Among Our Young People?

Humility and Allowing Ourselves to Not Know

A Better Money System

Our Failing Education System

How Much Good Can One Person Really Do?

New Zealand’s Leadership in a Living Planet View

How Our Money System Creates Scarcity

Where Does Addiction Come From?

Glimpses of Possibility: The Pain and Power

Let’s Shift From Control to Participation

What Does a World of Interbeing Look Like?

Will Technology Save Us?

What am I Here to Do?

A Critique of the Climate Narrative

What to Do When You Don’t Know What to Do

The Root of Separation

Is Competition Human Nature?

The Gift of Loss

How Do I Stay in the Story of Interbeing?

How Movements are Actually Started

Why We Shouldn’t Label Movements

Every Person Desires to Give Their Gift

The Convergence of Spirituality & Activism

What is Success?

You Are Life

A Revolutionary Mental Health Question

What is Mental Health?

Society Must Support the Changemakers

How Change Happens in the Story of Interbeing

Is Science a Religion?

How Change Happens in the Story of Separation

Why I Believe in a Living Planet View

The Impact of Ayahuasca & Other Psychedelics

Sacred Economics (2019 Remix)

The Need to Be Right (Sustainable Human) 10.2018

Living the Change Film: Full Length (2018)

Climate: A New Story (2018)

A New Story of Climate Change: New Frontiers (2018)

Beyond the Obsession with Number: Science and Non-Duality (2017)

What Is It Like to Be You?

Oprah Winfrey Interview (7.2017)

Word, Gift, & Money: A Conversation with Orland Bishop (11.2016)

The most important progress comes from letting go (10.2016)

The Speakeasy Forum at Wanderlust (2014)

How Do We Not Succumb to Depression Upon Reading the News (3.2016)

A Question for Everyone

More Beautiful World/Findhorn (9.2014)

Sacred Economics

Story Disruption & Morphogenesis (2015)

A Pattern to the Maze (Sustainable Man)

Dietary Transformation Learning Journey Intro (4.2017)

Empathy: Key to Effective Action (2.2017)

SESC: Vila Mariana (Sao Paulo Brazil) 11.2016

The Rebel Soul with Charles Eisenstein & Kelly Brogan M.D. (Full-length talk)

Pachamama Alliance: On Activism (9.2014)

A New Story of the People (Sustainable Man)

Occupy Wall St – The Revolution Is Love

Centre for Human Ecology, Glasgow 10.2014

Interview with Maria Scordialos: July 3, 2015

The Hive: Paonia, CO (7.2014)

Changing Consciousness Through Relationships

The New Mythology: 2.2015

Embercombe 5.2014

OuiShare 5.2015

Fairventure 2014: Universal Basic Income

The Two Great Stories

Sacred Economics (Portland Oregon Lecture)

More Beautiful World – North Atlantic Books (12.2013)

Open to Magic

Slow Living Summit (6.2014)

Schumacher College (5.2014)

Economics of Happiness Talk

Conversation with Polly Higgins, Oslo Norway

Jamaica Plain Forum (1.2014)

Extraenvironmentalist Interview (with Spanish Subtitles)

Sacred Economics and Sacred Law with Polly Higgins

The Gift Economy & the Commons with James Quilligan

Changes in the Money System with Margrit Kennedy

Introduction to Sacred Economics – The Guardian

London Real Podcast Interview

Conversation with Rev. Peter Owen Jones

The Leading Edge Interview Series

Interview Footage (“AWAKE” documentary)

The Living Planet

Charles w/ İhsan Eliaçık: Sacred Econ. & Social Islam

North Atlantic Books Webinar

Immense Possibilities: Sacred Economics

Sacred Conversation (Simon on the Sofa)

Open to Magic

Conversation with James Quilligan

The Revolution of the Gift Economy (Lecture 7.2012)

Warriors Without Weapons (7.2012)

It’s Time for A Better Narrative w/Chris Martensen (2012)

Interview for Money & Life Film

Occupy Wall St. – NYC ReEnvisioning Money

Money and the Turning of the Age

Deschooling Ourselves

Privacy Policy | Contact | Update Subscription

Charles Eisenstein

All content on this website is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. Feel free to copy and share.